United States of America eSeries: There’s no bipartisanship in DC. It’s oligarchy

05.20.21

Enjoying this newsletter? Forward to a friend!
Questions? Comments? what.matters@cnn.com

by Zachary B. Wolf

: The Latest

Israel and Hamas have agreed to a ceasefire. Israel and the Palestinian militant group Hamas have agreed to a ceasefire, after more than a week of conflict left hundreds dead, most of them Palestinians. The truce signals an end to the immediate bloodshed, but will likely leave both sides further apart than ever. More here.

Great read on House Speaker Nancy Pelosi's future. Democrats brace for a momentous decision: Will she run again?

Key passage: While Pelosi has previously indicated that this is her last term as speaker, she hasn't completely shut the door quite yet, fueling speculation she could ultimately seek to prolong her 18-year tenure ruling the House Democratic caucus.

Democrats and Republicans are watching her next moves closely, given that her decision would have a seismic impact across the political spectrum, fuel Democratic jockeying to replace her on Capitol Hill and prompt a scramble to replace her in her liberal-leaning district -- potentially with one of her daughters.

Policing outrage. His family says they were told he died in a car wreck. Video now shows Ronald Greene was kicked, dragged and Tased by police.

From CNN's report: In three brief video clips posted by the news agency, Greene can be heard apologizing to the officers that night, saying he was scared and supplicating for their mercy.

Federal authorities are now investigating the death, which is also the subject of a lawsuit.

This is NOT what the CDC recommended. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott is banning public schools from requiring masks.

More than half of adults are vaccinated in multiple states: From CNN's report: More than 48% of the US population has received at least one Covid-19 vaccine dose, according to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. And roughly 38.1% of the population is fully vaccinated, the data shows.

And in 19 states, at least half of adults are fully vaccinated. Those are Colorado, Connecticut, Hawaii, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Minnesota, Nebraska, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Dakota, Vermont, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin, as well as Washington, DC.

: Bipartisanship is out on Capitol Hill

The chances of the Senate agreeing to create a body to investigate this year's fatal assault on Congress are rapidly falling to zero.

But the fate of the January 6 commission -- and how Republicans have turned on the idea at the behest of former President Donald Trump, in whose name rioters attacked the seat of the legislative branch -- is, at this stage, really beside the point.

The larger thing we've learned from this latest episode is that, despite the pleas for unity Biden made when he took office, "bipartisanship" is basically dead right now on Capitol Hill.

What we have instead is an oligarchy. More on that very loaded term and why it's increasingly descriptive of Congress in a moment.

Democrats actually tried to be bipartisan with the January 6 commission. They bent over backward to bring Republicans on board. They accepted changes to the January 6 commission proposal and negotiated with those people tapped as emissaries by GOP leaders.

It wasn't enough. When House and Senate GOP leaders turned on the bill, that ended its chances.

This story is being rewritten over and over and over again. Bold prediction: It will be the same for an immigration reform bill, for investment in infrastructure, for improvements to the health care system -- all things most Americans say they want to see and that Trump himself said he wanted to accomplish. And all things that probably need to be accomplished.

But the prevailing wisdom right now in Washington is that if something can be blocked, it should be blocked, which is a shame since getting things done is supposedly what voters elect lawmakers to do.

Can't get everything you want? Block it! Specifically on the January 6 commission, you can agree with some Republicans that the commission is duplicative, that it's unnecessary, and that it would be partisan, despite the fact that it would be equally appointed by Republican and Democratic lawmakers.

Rather than simply vote against it, Republicans will block it in the Senate because they can, because Trump told them to, and because they don't want to do anything but paint Democrats as radical socialists.

The oligarchy argument. Former Michigan Rep. Justin Amash -- a Republican-turned-independent who is a former lawmaker because he broke with his party over supporting Trump -- gave an enlightening interview to CNN's David Axelrod, the Democratic political strategist, in which he described the life of a congressperson as one in which the Senate and House leaders, who control what legislation is considered, control pretty much everything.

"It's very much like an oligarchy," he said. "And I, I know when I use that phrase maybe or that word, people might think that's too strong, but I really believe that's what it's like. I don't think there is really a legislative body at this point."

Why not? "For the most part, the speaker of the House and the Senate majority leader, and to some extent the minority leaders in each party, run the show. Along with the president of the United States. And the other people are just there to press buttons...It's not a legislative body in the true sense."

That is exactly what happened with the commission, which was negotiated by lawmakers, but then killed by McCarthy and McConnell, who either caused their colleagues to oppose it or read the room.

Biden's optimism. Amash's bleak assessment of Capitol Hill is exactly the opposite of what Biden has been pushing, that Republicans can and may very well come to the table to negotiate. That's why Biden has, so far, opposed either pressuring fellow Democrats to upend the filibuster in the Senate, or use parliamentary games to push through what he can.

Amash would rather Biden play tougher with Congress.

"I don't think he, like a lot of other people in politics, recognize what is the true problem in our politics, that concentrated power, centralized power has really done a lot of damage to our legislative system and to our representative system. And there's no there's no going back to a world where people are at peace with each other and less partisan unless we correct that problem."

Read more and listen to it here.

Compromise is a dirty word. I tend to disagree with Amash on the remedy. The rules, and efforts to exploit them, created this problem. There is ample evidence that the partisanship has cemented in part because voters don't reward compromise and also because a unified minority doesn't have to compromise. Its senators can squash anything.

Exceptions that prove the rule. This week Congress did come together on a different piece of legislation -- a bill to address hate crimes stemming from the Covid pandemic and specifically targeted at Asian Americans, which should be the least controversial thing in the world.

Here's what it does, according to CNN's report: The legislation, called the Covid-19 Hate Crimes Act, will create a new position at the Justice Department to expedite review of potential Covid-19-related hate crimes and incidents reported at the federal, state or local level.

It will also direct the Justice Department and Health and Human Services to work with community-based organizations to issue guidance raising awareness of hate crimes during the pandemic, and would require the attorney general to issue guidance to work with state and local law enforcement agencies to establish online reporting of them.

That's not exactly a bipartisan agreement, but rather the obvious thing to do. Sixty-three Republicans still opposed it.

More to the point and more controversial, for some reason, was a supplemental spending bill Democrats pushed through the House to provide $1.9 billion in new spending to secure the Capitol. That proposal, despite the Capitol being attacked a few months ago, was passed on a party line vote. Several Democrats voted "present" because they were nervous about giving new money for policing. Three Democrats voted no.

Every Republican was opposed to the security funding.

Some have downplayed the severity of the attack, which seems silly considering all the video of the rioters.

Others, like Rep. Tom Cole, said he opposed the funding because Democrats weren't being bipartisan enough.

"It's truly disappointing that Democrats were unwilling to continue to work towards an agreement with Republicans on a matter of this magnitude. And given that the Senate is in no hurry to take up this legislation, a few additional weeks of discussion could, and likely would, have led to a bipartisan product instead of a product destined for the legislative graveyard," Cole said.

He voted no on the January 6 commission proposal, too. That bipartisan bill is similarly destined for the legislative graveyard.